Spurs defy transfer spend frenzy

Feb 25, 2012 by     7    Posted under: Sport

Harry Redknapp’s Spurs have defied the now commonly accepted rule that you have to spend big in the transfer window to achieve success.

Tottenham are positioned third in the table, despite spending a meagre £6.3m on bringing new players in compared to the heavyweights of Manchester City, Chelsea and Liverpool.

With a transfer spend of only £120,000 per point earned and taking Spurs to third place in the Premier League, no wonder Redknapp is favourite to take the England job for EURO 2012.

Take a look at my infographic to find how your team compares. The graphic represents the value of each point earned in terms of transfer money spent for the 2011-12 Premier League season – which includes both the Summer and January transfer windows combined.

The data is correct as on 24 February, 2012.

Premier League Transfer Value for Money

Infographic: Transfer spend per point earned

March update:
> Note that there are some limitations to the data, in so far as the transfer spend shown is gross transfer spend (i.e. total transfer spend in) for the season and not net transfer spend (i.e. total transfers in – total transfers out) plus it excludes wages.
> To improve in future graphics, I hope will use net transfer spend (or ratio) and may compare the data for the last three seasons to gain fairer and perhaps more accurate findings, particularly since it may take a season or two for the full effects of new transfers in or transfers out to make a noticeable impact on a team’s performance.

  • J Smith

    Maybe the figure should take into account more than one season…

    • http://twitter.com/wezthewiz Wesley Young

      This is definitely something I could add, considering it may take a season or so for transfers to make a noticeable impact to the team. Thanks for your comment.

  • http://twitter.com/jameswelchseo James Welch

    An excellent visualisation, Wesley.

  • Jason

    what about revenue from transfers out? net transfer value (eg liverpool/torres etc) might be fairer

    • http://twitter.com/wezthewiz Wesley Young

      This is a very good point. A net transfer value (transfers in – transfers out) could make results slightly less skewed. Although, I might end up with tricky negative values in some cases (eg. Villa sold Ashley Young and Stewart Downing totalling £37m vs £13.25m spent on bringing in Given and N’Zogbia). Thank you for your comment. I will certainly look into this.

  • http://twitter.com/pauledwards80 Paul

    Good visualisation.

    A couple of points though. I think having the circles increase in size with a decrease in spend per point is misleading. At first glance just looking at the red circles without the numbers I thought that Spurs had the highest spend per point as the red circle was largest.

    I think the data you have is perfect for a nice simple bar chart sorted high to low. That would visualise the data in a nice clear way.

    Also as noted in the other comments there are limitations to the data used, e.g. gross spend not net, excludes wages, limited time frame etc. This is fine as no data is perfect but I would have liked to see you note the limitations in the introduction.

    • http://twitter.com/wezthewiz Wesley Young

      Thank you for your comment. I first thought that the circles increasing in size in relation to cost per point may be a little misleading too, although, the other way around the data did not seem to portray the strong correlation between money spent and points earned this season – particularly in the cases of Spurs, Everton and West Brom.

      I appreciate your feedback and in this particular case, a bar chart may have reflected the data clearer. This has been very much an experimental process. I will amend my post to identify the limitations of my graphic and certainly take your advice on board for future graphics. Thanks again Paul; I am always looking for ways to improve.

About Me

Wesley Young

Wesley Young

Freelance Copywriter specialising in tech start-ups and app reviews

First Class Enterprise Computing graduate interested in tech start-ups, open data, infographics and app reviews. MA Web Journalism graduate from the University of Sheffield.

Freelancer for VoucherCodes.co.uk and my own personal blog, Wesley Writes, and tech news site, SteelData.

Worked for Forge Press, the Manchester Evening News and Press Association Sports.

Follow Me on Twitter